Elongated vs. Round Toilets – Pros, Cons, And Comparisons

I. Introduction

Welcome to the ultimate guide on elongated vs. round toilets. If you’re in the market for a new toilet, you’ve probably come across these two popular options. But which one is right for you? In this article, we’ll explore the pros, cons, and comparisons of elongated and round toilets, helping you make an informed decision for your bathroom.

When it comes to choosing a toilet, it’s important to consider both functionality and aesthetics. Elongated toilets have a longer, oval-shaped bowl, while round toilets have a more compact, circular bowl. The shape of the bowl can impact comfort, especially for individuals with mobility issues or larger body frames.

One of the key advantages of elongated toilets is their added comfort. The elongated shape provides more surface area, making it easier to sit on and providing better support for your thighs. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals who spend extended periods of time on the toilet, such as the elderly or those with certain medical conditions.

On the other hand, round toilets are a great option for smaller bathrooms or powder rooms with limited space. Their compact design allows for more maneuverability, making them ideal for tight spaces. Additionally, round toilets tend to be more affordable compared to elongated toilets, making them a budget-friendly choice.

Ultimately, the decision between an elongated and round toilet comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of your bathroom. In the following sections, we’ll delve deeper into the pros, cons, and comparisons of these two types of toilets, providing you with all the information you need to make the right choice.

II. Understanding elongated toilets

When it comes to choosing the right toilet for your bathroom, there are several factors to consider. One of the main considerations is the shape of the toilet bowl. Two popular options are elongated toilets and round toilets. In this section, we will delve deeper into elongated toilets, exploring their definition, characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages.

A. Definition and Characteristics

Elongated toilets are toilets that have an oval-shaped bowl, as opposed to the round bowl found in round toilets. The elongated shape provides a larger seating area and a more comfortable experience for users. The dimensions of an elongated toilet bowl typically measure around 18.5 inches in length, compared to the 16.5 inches of a round toilet bowl.

One of the key characteristics of elongated toilets is their sleek and modern appearance. The elongated shape adds a touch of elegance to any bathroom, making it a popular choice for homeowners who value aesthetics. Additionally, elongated toilets tend to have a taller height, known as comfort height, which makes it easier for individuals with mobility issues or disabilities to sit down and stand up.

Furthermore, elongated toilets are known for their superior flushing performance. The larger bowl size allows for a more powerful flush, effectively removing waste with minimal water usage. This not only contributes to water conservation but also helps in maintaining a clean and hygienic bathroom environment.

B. Advantages

Elongated toilets offer several advantages over their round counterparts. Firstly, the elongated shape provides added comfort during use. The larger seating area ensures that users have ample space and support, reducing the risk of discomfort or strain.

Secondly, elongated toilets are particularly suitable for individuals with certain health conditions or physical limitations. The comfort height feature, combined with the elongated bowl shape, makes it easier for people with mobility issues to use the toilet independently and with minimal effort.

Another advantage of elongated toilets is their superior flushing power. The larger bowl size allows for a more forceful flush, effectively removing waste and preventing clogs. This can save homeowners from the hassle of frequent plunging or calling a plumber.

Lastly, elongated toilets are often considered more hygienic compared to round toilets. The larger bowl size and powerful flush ensure that waste is thoroughly removed, leaving no residue behind. This contributes to a cleaner and more sanitary bathroom environment.

C. Disadvantages

While elongated toilets offer numerous benefits, it is important to consider their disadvantages as well. One of the main drawbacks of elongated toilets is their size. The elongated shape requires more space in the bathroom, which can be a limitation for smaller or compact bathrooms.

In addition, the larger size of elongated toilets may not be suitable for households with young children. Children may find it uncomfortable or challenging to use an elongated toilet due to the larger seating area and taller height. In such cases, a round toilet may be a more practical choice.

Furthermore, elongated toilets tend to be more expensive than round toilets. The additional features, such as the elongated bowl shape and comfort height, contribute to the higher price tag. This can be a deterrent for budget-conscious homeowners.

Lastly, the availability of replacement parts and accessories for elongated toilets may be limited compared to round toilets. This can pose a challenge when it comes to repairs or upgrades in the future.

III. Understanding round toilets

In this section, we will delve into the definition, characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages of round toilets. As an experienced plumber with over 10 years of expertise in the field, I have encountered various types of toilets and can provide valuable insights into the topic.

A. Definition and characteristics

Round toilets, also known as compact toilets, are a popular choice for smaller bathrooms or spaces with limited room. These toilets have a circular bowl shape, which allows for efficient use of space. The dimensions of a round toilet typically range from 25 to 28 inches in depth and 19 to 20 inches in width.

One of the key characteristics of round toilets is their ability to fit comfortably in tight spaces. This makes them an ideal option for powder rooms, half-baths, or bathrooms with limited square footage. Additionally, round toilets are often more affordable compared to elongated toilets, making them a budget-friendly choice for homeowners.

Despite their compact size, round toilets still offer a comfortable seating experience. The circular bowl shape provides adequate support and stability, ensuring a comfortable position for users of all ages and sizes.

B. Advantages

Round toilets come with several advantages that make them a popular choice among homeowners:

• Space-saving: As mentioned earlier, round toilets are designed to fit in smaller bathrooms or tight spaces. Their compact size allows for more flexibility in bathroom layout and design.
• Affordability: Round toilets are often more affordable compared to elongated toilets. This makes them an attractive option for homeowners on a budget or those looking to save on bathroom renovations.
• Easier to clean: The circular bowl shape of round toilets makes them easier to clean compared to elongated toilets. There are no hard-to-reach corners or crevices, reducing the time and effort required for maintenance.
• Comfortable seating: Despite their smaller size, round toilets still provide a comfortable seating experience. The circular bowl shape offers adequate support and stability, ensuring a pleasant experience for users.

C. Disadvantages

While round toilets have their advantages, it’s important to consider the potential drawbacks as well:

• Less seating space: Due to their compact size, round toilets may provide less seating space compared to elongated toilets. This can be a concern for individuals who prefer a larger seating area or those with mobility issues.
• Not ideal for taller individuals: The circular bowl shape of round toilets may not provide enough legroom for taller individuals. This can result in a less comfortable seating position for those with longer legs.
• Less variety: While round toilets are widely available, they may offer less variety in terms of design and features compared to elongated toilets. Homeowners looking for specific styles or advanced functionalities may find limited options with round toilets.

It’s important to consider your specific needs and bathroom requirements when choosing between round and elongated toilets. If space is a concern and you prioritize affordability, ease of cleaning, and a comfortable seating experience, a round toilet may be the perfect choice for your bathroom.

IV. Pros of elongated toilets

Elongated toilets have become increasingly popular in recent years due to their numerous advantages over round toilets. In this section, we will explore the various benefits of elongated toilets, including comfort and ergonomics, improved hygiene, suitability for larger individuals, and enhanced aesthetics.

A. Comfort and ergonomics

One of the primary reasons why many people prefer elongated toilets is the enhanced comfort they offer. The elongated shape provides a larger seating area, allowing for a more relaxed and comfortable experience. This is especially beneficial for individuals with mobility issues or those who spend a significant amount of time on the toilet.

Moreover, the elongated shape of these toilets provides better support for the thighs and buttocks, reducing strain on the muscles and joints. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals with back or hip problems, as it promotes a more natural and comfortable sitting position.

Additionally, elongated toilets are designed with ergonomics in mind. The elongated bowl shape allows for better alignment of the body, reducing the risk of discomfort or strain during use. This makes them an excellent choice for individuals seeking a toilet that prioritizes both comfort and functionality.

B. Improved hygiene

Elongated toilets also offer improved hygiene compared to round toilets. The elongated shape of the bowl provides more space between the user and the toilet rim, minimizing the chances of contact and reducing the spread of germs and bacteria.

Furthermore, elongated toilets often come equipped with advanced flushing systems that ensure efficient waste removal and thorough cleaning of the bowl. This helps maintain a higher level of cleanliness and hygiene, providing peace of mind to users.

Some elongated toilets also feature additional hygiene-focused features, such as self-cleaning capabilities or antimicrobial surfaces. These features further enhance the cleanliness and hygiene of the toilet, making it an attractive option for individuals who prioritize sanitation.

C. Suitable for larger individuals

Elongated toilets are particularly suitable for larger individuals or those with a larger body frame. The elongated shape provides more space and a larger seating area, accommodating individuals with greater comfort and ease.

Individuals who struggle with mobility or have difficulty fitting comfortably on round toilets can greatly benefit from the larger size and spaciousness of elongated toilets. The additional room allows for better maneuverability and reduces the risk of discomfort or strain during use.

Moreover, elongated toilets often have a higher weight capacity compared to round toilets, making them a more suitable choice for individuals who require a sturdier and more robust toilet.

D. Enhanced aesthetics

Aside from their functional advantages, elongated toilets also offer enhanced aesthetics compared to round toilets. The elongated shape provides a sleek and modern look, adding a touch of elegance to any bathroom.

Elongated toilets come in a wide range of designs, styles, and finishes, allowing homeowners to choose a toilet that complements their bathroom decor. Whether it’s a contemporary or traditional bathroom, there is an elongated toilet design to suit every taste and preference.

Furthermore, the elongated shape of the toilet bowl creates a visually appealing and balanced look, adding a sense of sophistication to the overall bathroom design. This can significantly elevate the aesthetic appeal of the space and create a more luxurious and inviting atmosphere.

V. Cons of elongated toilets

When it comes to choosing the right toilet for your bathroom, there are several factors to consider. In this section, we will explore the cons of elongated toilets, including space requirements, higher cost, and limited availability of models and designs.

A. Space requirements

Elongated toilets are known for their elongated bowl shape, which provides additional comfort and space for the user. However, this elongated shape also means that these toilets require more space in the bathroom compared to round toilets.

For smaller bathrooms or tight spaces, the extra length of an elongated toilet may pose a challenge. It can limit your options for toilet placement and may make the bathroom feel cramped. It’s important to carefully measure the available space in your bathroom before opting for an elongated toilet.

Additionally, if you have a bathroom with an existing round toilet, switching to an elongated toilet may require modifications to the plumbing or even the bathroom layout. This can add to the overall cost and inconvenience of installing an elongated toilet.

B. Higher cost

Another drawback of elongated toilets is their higher cost compared to round toilets. The elongated bowl design and the additional materials required for manufacturing elongated toilets contribute to their higher price tag.

While the price difference may not be significant for some, it can be a deciding factor for budget-conscious individuals or those who are looking to save on bathroom renovations. It’s important to consider your budget and weigh the benefits of an elongated toilet against its higher cost.

However, it’s worth noting that the higher cost of elongated toilets can be justified by the added comfort and space they provide. If you prioritize comfort and are willing to invest a bit more, an elongated toilet may be the right choice for you.

C. Limited availability of models and designs

Compared to round toilets, elongated toilets have a more limited availability of models and designs. This can make it challenging to find the perfect elongated toilet that matches your bathroom aesthetics and preferences.

While round toilets come in a wide variety of styles, sizes, and designs, the options for elongated toilets may be more limited. This can be especially true if you have specific requirements or preferences, such as a certain color or a specific flushing mechanism.

It’s important to do thorough research and explore different brands and manufacturers to find an elongated toilet that meets your needs. Consider reading user reviews and seeking expert recommendations to ensure you make an informed decision.

VI. Pros of round toilets

When it comes to choosing a toilet for your bathroom, there are many factors to consider. One of the main decisions you’ll need to make is whether to go for a round toilet or an elongated one. In this section, we will explore the pros of round toilets and why they might be the right choice for your bathroom.

A. Space-saving design

One of the biggest advantages of round toilets is their space-saving design. Round toilets are typically smaller in size compared to elongated toilets, making them a great option for bathrooms with limited space. If you have a small bathroom or a powder room, a round toilet can help maximize the available space and create a more open and spacious feel.

Not only do round toilets take up less floor space, but they also have a smaller footprint, which means they protrude less into the bathroom. This can be particularly beneficial if you have a narrow bathroom or if you want to create more room for other fixtures or storage options.

Additionally, round toilets are often a preferred choice for older homes or buildings with smaller bathrooms, where space is at a premium. Their compact size allows for easier installation and can help maintain the overall aesthetic of the bathroom without compromising on functionality.

B. Cost-effective option

Another advantage of round toilets is that they are often more cost-effective compared to elongated toilets. Round toilets tend to be less expensive to manufacture and purchase, making them a budget-friendly choice for homeowners.

Not only are round toilets typically more affordable upfront, but they can also save you money in the long run. Round toilets generally require less water for each flush compared to elongated toilets. This can result in lower water bills over time, making them a more economical option for households looking to reduce their water consumption and save on utility costs.

Furthermore, round toilets are often easier to maintain and repair. Their simpler design and smaller size make them less prone to mechanical issues, and replacement parts are generally more readily available and affordable.

C. Wide range of models and designs available

Round toilets offer a wide range of models and designs to choose from, ensuring that you can find one that suits your personal preferences and bathroom decor. Whether you prefer a traditional or modern style, there is a round toilet out there that will complement your bathroom aesthetic.

You can find round toilets in various materials, such as porcelain, ceramic, or even eco-friendly options like bamboo or recycled materials. They are also available in different colors and finishes, allowing you to match them with your existing bathroom fixtures and accessories.

Furthermore, round toilets come in different heights and seat options, providing added comfort and customization. Whether you prefer a standard height or a chair height toilet, you can find a round toilet that meets your specific needs.

VII. Cons of round toilets

When it comes to choosing the right toilet for your bathroom, there are several factors to consider. One of the main decisions you’ll need to make is whether to go for a round or elongated toilet bowl. While round toilets have their advantages, there are also some drawbacks that you should be aware of. In this section, we will explore the cons of round toilets.

A. Less comfortable for some individuals

One of the main drawbacks of round toilets is that they can be less comfortable for some individuals. The round shape of the toilet bowl means that there is less surface area for sitting compared to elongated toilets. This can be an issue for people who prefer a larger seating area or those who have mobility issues and require more space to maneuver.

Furthermore, round toilets may not be suitable for individuals who are taller or have longer legs. The smaller size of the round bowl can make it uncomfortable for these individuals to sit for extended periods of time. It is important to consider the comfort of all users when choosing a toilet for your bathroom.

B. Potential hygiene issues

Another disadvantage of round toilets is that they can pose potential hygiene issues. The round shape of the bowl can make it more difficult to clean thoroughly, especially in hard-to-reach areas. This can lead to the buildup of bacteria and germs, which can be unhygienic and pose health risks.

Additionally, the smaller size of the round bowl can make it more challenging to aim properly when using the toilet. This can result in splashes and spills, which can further contribute to hygiene concerns. Regular and thorough cleaning is essential to maintain good hygiene with round toilets.

C. Not ideal for larger individuals

Round toilets may not be ideal for larger individuals. The smaller size of the round bowl can make it uncomfortable for individuals with a larger build. It may feel cramped and restrictive, making it difficult to use the toilet comfortably.

Moreover, the weight capacity of round toilets may be lower compared to elongated toilets. This can be a concern for individuals who are heavier, as the toilet may not be able to support their weight adequately. It is important to consider the weight capacity of the toilet when choosing the right one for your needs.

VIII. Comparisons between elongated and round toilets

When it comes to choosing a toilet for your bathroom, one of the key decisions you’ll need to make is whether to go for an elongated or round toilet. Both options have their own unique features and benefits, so it’s important to understand the differences between them before making a final decision. In this section, we will compare elongated and round toilets in terms of size and dimensions, flushing capabilities, installation requirements, and maintenance and cleaning.

A. Size and dimensions

One of the primary differences between elongated and round toilets is their size and dimensions. Elongated toilets are typically larger and longer in shape compared to round toilets. They provide more sitting space and are generally considered more comfortable, especially for individuals with larger body frames or mobility issues. On the other hand, round toilets are more compact and better suited for smaller bathrooms or spaces where saving space is a priority.

When considering the size and dimensions of a toilet, it’s important to measure the available space in your bathroom and ensure that the toilet you choose fits comfortably without obstructing other fixtures or creating cramped conditions.

B. Flushing capabilities

Another important aspect to consider when comparing elongated and round toilets is their flushing capabilities. Both types of toilets are designed to effectively flush waste, but there are some differences in performance.

Elongated toilets typically have a larger surface area and a deeper bowl, which allows for a more powerful and efficient flush. This can help prevent clogs and ensure that waste is effectively removed with each flush. Round toilets, while still capable of providing a satisfactory flush, may not have the same level of power and efficiency as elongated toilets.

It’s worth noting that the flushing capabilities of a toilet can also depend on other factors such as the design of the bowl and the type of flushing mechanism used. It’s always a good idea to read user reviews and expert recommendations to get a better understanding of the flushing performance of specific brands or models.

C. Installation requirements

When it comes to installation, elongated and round toilets have similar requirements. Both types of toilets can be installed using a standard floor flange and wax ring. However, elongated toilets may require slightly more space due to their larger size.

It’s important to ensure that your bathroom has enough clearance for the toilet you choose, especially if you opt for an elongated toilet. This includes considering the distance from the wall to the center of the toilet’s flange, as well as the space needed for comfortable use and cleaning.

D. Maintenance and cleaning

Maintenance and cleaning are essential aspects of toilet ownership. When comparing elongated and round toilets, there are a few factors to consider in terms of maintenance and cleaning requirements.

Elongated toilets, with their larger size and deeper bowls, may require slightly more effort to clean compared to round toilets. The larger surface area and shape of elongated toilets can make it harder to reach certain areas, requiring more thorough cleaning. However, many elongated toilets now come with features such as glazed surfaces or antimicrobial coatings, which can help prevent stains and make cleaning easier.

Round toilets, on the other hand, with their more compact size and simpler shape, are generally easier to clean and maintain. The smaller surface area and bowl shape make it easier to reach all areas for cleaning, reducing the risk of buildup or stains.

Ultimately, the choice between an elongated and round toilet will depend on your personal preferences, the available space in your bathroom, and any specific needs or requirements you may have. By considering the size and dimensions, flushing capabilities, installation requirements, and maintenance and cleaning aspects of both options, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs and ensures a comfortable and functional toilet for your bathroom.

IX. Frequently asked questions

A. Question 1

What are the main differences between elongated and round toilets?

When it comes to choosing a toilet for your bathroom, one of the main decisions you’ll need to make is whether to go for an elongated or round toilet. The main difference between the two is the shape of the bowl. Elongated toilets have an oval-shaped bowl, while round toilets have a circular bowl.

Elongated toilets are generally considered more comfortable, as they provide more space for sitting. They are also preferred by taller individuals, as the extra length provides more legroom. On the other hand, round toilets are a better choice for smaller bathrooms, as they take up less space. They are also often more affordable than elongated toilets.

B. Question 2

Which type of toilet is more suitable for small bathrooms?

If you have a small bathroom, a round toilet is usually the more suitable option. The compact size of a round toilet allows it to fit into tight spaces more easily, making it ideal for bathrooms with limited square footage. Additionally, round toilets are often more affordable than elongated toilets, which can be a deciding factor for those on a budget.

C. Question 3

Are elongated toilets more comfortable than round toilets?

Yes, elongated toilets are generally considered more comfortable than round toilets. The elongated shape of the bowl provides more surface area for sitting, making it more comfortable for most people. The extra length also allows for more legroom, which can be especially beneficial for taller individuals.

D. Question 4

Do elongated toilets cost more than round toilets?

Generally, elongated toilets tend to be slightly more expensive than round toilets. This is partly due to the larger size and increased material required to manufacture elongated toilets. However, the price difference between the two types of toilets is usually not significant, and it ultimately depends on the specific brand and model you choose.

E. Question 5

Can I replace a round toilet with an elongated toilet?

Yes, it is possible to replace a round toilet with an elongated toilet. However, it’s important to consider the available space in your bathroom before making the switch. Elongated toilets require more space due to their larger size, so you’ll need to ensure that there is enough room for the elongated toilet to fit comfortably. If you have a small bathroom, it may be more practical to stick with a round toilet.

Remember, when choosing between an elongated and round toilet, it’s essential to consider factors such as comfort, space availability, and budget. Ultimately, the decision should be based on your individual needs and preferences.